September Banlist

[kizza the shocking]

Right here is what I think should happen this list

Ban Swap frog, resuce cat (they prob wont thoguh) and maybe brain control

limit Darksoul, stardust dragon, trib infectiong virus, trebron frog (possibly), launcher

semi limited E-T, D draw, Substitoad, Burial, E Hero Stratos, D draw, besti, COTLB

Unlimited  Necro Gardna, Skill drain, black whirwind

I thikn this will slow down the format alot make the OTK deck's go away but at the same time it's not a slow format. This is my personal opinion

[Taylor]

Personally I think they can't ban swap frog it hurts too many decks to ban it
frog control
frog monarch
frog ftk
exodia frog

I think the frog ban will go like this

Swap Frog, Semi-Limited
Substitoad, Semi-Limited
Mass Driver, Limited or Banned

[kizza the shocking]

Exodia frog isn't a deck anymore and all 3 of those deck are unstable atm and putting swap frog to 1 doesn't kill  the FTK much, needs to be banned.

[Taylor]

What I am saying is with that is it's not killing the ftk it just makes it harder to do the ftk they shouldn't by all means get rid of the ftk but limit so it's so much harder to do

[lukasbeeler]

Banned-

Brain Control
Giant Trunade
Ronintoadin (personal oppion)(cos then normal frog isnt hurrt as much just OTK)
Infernity Barrier (stupid card)
Rescue Cat (can be be +2/3)

Limited-

Victory dragon
XXsaber Darksoul
Infernity Archfiend
Infernity Launcher
Tribe Infecting Virus
Dark Hole.. (maybe)
Treeborn Frog

Semi- Limited


Infenity Necromancer
Infenity Beetle
Lumina
ETele
GladBeast Bestari
Burial From a Different Dimension
Mind Control (cos if brain banned)
Charge otlb
Allure of Darkness
Solemn Judgement
LaDD
Rota
Level Limit Area B
Gravity Bind
Mind Crush
Mezuki
ddraw

Unlimited

Black WhirlWind
Reasoning
Ultimate Offering
Mind master
Demise King of Armegedonn
magic Cylinder
Necro Gardna

[chris]

darksoul to 1 because 2 are playable, jd to 1 to make it same as dad, rescue cat to none because its going to be broken with the next set

[Azrael]

-snip-

You sure are hitting Infernities hard.

Anyway...

Mind Master should really, really, not go to three.
With the new Gusta archtype that's being released (I think it's being released anyway), it's possible to do an infinite draw loop with Mind Master, Calm Silent Gusta, and Brain Research Lab.
So yeah, that wont happen.

Charge of the Light Brigade to two? Why?

[afroninja]

Ok Heres My Opinion
*=either

Banned:
Cat - Just Too Cool I'd Rather Be FTK'ed Than Cold Wave Cat
Mass Driver*- Banned, Most FTK's Are Stopped

Restricted:
Mass Driver* - Nuff Said
Launcher - Well, Its Good :L
Archfiend - Searcher, Kinda Like Charge In Theroy They Put That To 1, This Should Go To 1
Faultrol - Too Good
Darksoul - This WON'T Get Hit As Japan Don't Have This Card So Its Not Much Of A Threat Over There
Ronintoadin -FTK
Substitoad - Awsum Card
Dandylion - Slow Down Dandywarrior
Treeborn Frog - Well It Was At One, Lets Keep It That Way
Crush Card - I Would LOVE Another Format With This, Even If It's The Last One We Can Have

Semi Limited:
Swap Frog  -Constant Foolish
Mezuki - Well With Burial At One I Don't See This As A Problem
Drill Warrior - Can't Be Stopped
Lumina - Give Lightsworn Back One More Thing
D - Draw - Meh? Bring The D-Engine Back
War Chariot - I Effing Hate This Card ¬_¬
Barrier - Can't See This Happining, Again, Japan Don't Have This card.

CBA To Add More Feel Free To Critisize IDC

Adam 'Afroninja' Stock

[Taylor]

After all of this argueing on this topic I have devised another list after all of these comments have been made just to see what people think.

Banned
Rescue Cat
Mass Driver

Limited
Infernity Launcher
XX-Saber Darksoul
Judgement Dragon
Roindintoadin
Archlord Kristya

Semi-Limited
Lumina the Lightsworn Summoner
XX-Saber Faultroll
Substitoad
Infernity Archfeind
Infernity Barrier
Gladiator Beast Bestiari
Gladiator Beast Gyzarus
Gladiator Beast War Chariot
Swap Frog
Caius the Shadow Monarch
Necro Gardna
Destiny Draw

Unlimited
Snipe Hunter

[kizza the shocking]

I'm gunna redo my list because the new stuff c ame out and the discussion.


band

Rescue cat
Swap Frog

limited

Infernity Launcher
XX-Saber Darksoul
Substitoad
Infernity Barrier
Tribe Infecting virus
Infernaty Archfiend


Semi-Limited


Necro Gardna
GB Bestari
LS Lumina
Allure
D Draw
Pot Of Greadosity (the new card)
Foolish Burial
Infernity Necromancer
E hero stratos
XX-Saber faughtroll


Unlimited

Black wirlwind
Magic Cylanders

[lukasbeeler]

something i found:

Banned ? (unconfirmed)

Rescue Cat
Substitoad
Cold Wave


Limited 8 (working on it)

Caius the Shadow Monarch
Magician of Faith
Treeborn Frog
Infernity Launcher
Black Whirlwind
Dark Hole
Pot of Duality
Bottomless Trap Hole

Semi-limited 8 (working on it)

Foolish Burial
Pot of Avarice
Icarus Attack
Infernity Archfiend
Burial from a Different Dimension
Foolish Burial
Gladiator Beast War Chariot
Dark Grepher

Unlimited 3 (confirmed)?

Ultimate Offering
United We Stand
Skill Drain

[Taylor]

I saw that too but I didn't want to post it in case that its not all confirmed but there is another list here which I found too.

FORBIDDEN

None / Unknown

LIMITED

Substitoad
Infernity Launcher
Infernity Archfiend
Black Whirlwind
Pot of Duality
Bottomless Trap Hole
Dandylion
Blackwing - Sirocco the Dawn

SEMI-LIMITED

Foolish Burial
Icarus Attack
Snipe Hunter
Dark Grepher
Destiny Draw
Pot of Avarice
Blackwing - Kalut the Moon Shadow
Machina Gearframe

UNLIMITED

Skill Drain
Ultimate Offering

This is another list which is rumoured and unconfirmed because there is absoulotely no x saber restriction

[kizza the shocking]

Also frog OTK doesn't really get hit. I don't see that beeing the list because nothing is getting band.

[Azrael]

This is apparently confirmed.
Konami is on drugs.
Seriously.

--

Banned
Substitoad
Rescue Cat
Heavy Storm
Brain Control

Limited
Trishula
Infernity Gun
Black Whirlwind
Monster Reborn
Dark Hole
Royal Opression

Semi-Limited
Chaos Sorcerer
Snipe Hunter
MST
Ojama Trio
Magic Cylinder

No longer Restricted
Goblin Zombie
Cyber Dragon
Treeborn Frog
Black Rose Dragon
United We Stand
Royal Decree

[kizza the shocking]

Well it gets rid of frogs but apart form that it makes the format even quicker. OK rescue cat is gone but royal opp at 1 makes special easy and chaos back at 2 is mad.


STUPID BAND LIST